The bitter succession battle over the estate of prominent businessman Dr James Musinguzi Garuga has taken another dramatic turn, with three of his four children publicly declaring their support for their widowed mother, Dr Peace Musinguzi, in an increasingly acrimonious dispute with their elder brother, Alwyn Carl Musinguzi.
In a strongly worded statement dated November 6, 2026, Rowena, Johnnie and Phillip Musinguzi accused Alwyn of frustrating their mother’s attempts to administer their late father’s estate and allegedly working with former minister and businessman Matthew Rukikaire to mount a campaign of harassment against members of the family, business associates and individuals who previously dealt with their father.
The siblings, who say they have endured more than a year of sustained harassment, maintain that their mother was the family’s preferred choice to administer the estate following Garuga’s death and that they supported her application for letters of administration.
However, their elder brother allegedly filed a caveat opposing the grant of letters of administration to their mother, setting off a prolonged legal confrontation that has now spilled into the management of companies, ownership of land, frozen bank accounts and the deployment of armed security personnel.
The latest statement represents a significant escalation in a family disagreement that has increasingly become public, with competing accusations of financial impropriety, interference with company assets, questionable land transactions and the alleged misuse of state institutions.
At the heart of the disagreement is who should control the estate of a businessman whose interests included extensive landholdings, ranches, property developments, hotels and shares in several companies.

The battle for control of the estate
Garuga, a prominent businessman from the Kigezi sub-region, died at Nakasero Hospital on August 6, 2025, aged 71, after battling cancer and other health complications.
His death left behind his widow, Peace, and four children, including Alwyn, who has since emerged as the central figure in the succession dispute.
The family’s disagreements reportedly began almost immediately after his death, with Alwyn challenging his mother’s suitability to administer the estate and questioning the extent to which she had disclosed his father’s assets.
In court proceedings, Alwyn reportedly estimated the estate at more than Shs1 trillion, citing a collection of properties and business interests that he believes should be accounted for in the succession process.
Among the assets cited were a mansion in Mbuya reportedly valued at more than Shs6 billion, a 20-acre country home in Rugyeyo, Kanungu District, estimated at Shs20 billion, more than 152 land titles held under Garuga Properties Limited, ranches in Ngoma and Kyankwanzi, shares in Kigezi Highland Tea Limited and Savanna Resort Hotel in Kanungu.
However, Peace has disputed aspects of her son’s valuation, arguing that several of the companies and properties he lists are separate legal entities and should not automatically be treated as her late husband’s personal estate. The dispute over administration eventually reached the High Court Family Division.
In a ruling delivered on February 20, 2026, Justice John Eudes Keitirima appointed the Administrator General, Victor Manzi, as administrator pendente lite, meaning a temporary administrator pending determination of the substantive succession dispute.
The judge declined Alwyn’s application for joint temporary administration, observing that the beneficiaries had developed serious disagreements and could not work harmoniously.
Justice Keitirima reasoned that giving the disputing relatives joint control would create further disruption and acrimony, potentially exposing the estate to waste.
The appointment of the Administrator General was therefore intended to preserve the estate while the court determined the underlying dispute. This means that despite the latest declaration by the three siblings supporting their mother, the temporary administration arrangement remains an important part of the legal background to the dispute.

Three siblings reject Alwyn’s claims
In their November 6 statement, Rowena, Johnnie and Phillip sought to challenge what they described as Alwyn’s claims to authority over their late father’s estate. They insist that their mother was the family’s agreed choice to administer the estate and that Alwyn’s opposition disrupted an arrangement they had reached following their father’s death.
“Despite multiple claims by our brother, Alwyn, he is neither an administrator of our late father’s estate nor has he ever been appointed our father’s heir,” the siblings stated.
They further alleged that Alwyn had been estranged from their father for several years before his death, following legal disputes in which he sued Garuga and companies associated with him in 2018 and 2019.
The siblings say the disagreements between father and son are documented in court proceedings, media reports and police records.
Their position is that Alwyn’s subsequent involvement in disputes surrounding the family businesses should not be confused with a lawful appointment as administrator of the estate.
They also accuse him of joining hands with Matthew Rukikaire, a businessman who has been involved in a prolonged legal dispute with Incafex Limited, one of the companies associated with the late Garuga.
The siblings allege that the partnership has been used to pursue their mother, family members, business associates and other individuals who previously conducted business with their father.
Rukikaire’s involvement is particularly significant because his disagreement with Incafex reportedly dates back more than two decades and concerns substantial interests in the company’s properties.

The Rukikaire connection and the Incafex dispute
One of the central battlegrounds in the unfolding family war is Incafex Limited, where the late Garuga reportedly held a 20 per cent shareholding in his personal capacity, while Garuga Properties Limited held another 70 per cent.
The three siblings say these ownership details are verifiable through records at the Uganda Registration Services Bureau (URSB).
They accuse Rukikaire of attempting to claim a substantial portion of the company by presenting himself as an agent of foreign investors.
According to the siblings, Rukikaire has been involved in court proceedings concerning Incafex for approximately 22 years, pursuing what they describe as a significant portion of the company’s interests.
They further claim that Rukikaire and Alwyn have used the dispute to draw state institutions into what should largely be civil disagreements over company ownership, shareholder interests and estate administration.
The siblings also point to correspondence from President Yoweri Museveni addressed to the Attorney General and the Minister of Lands, Housing and Urban Development, which they say has been misrepresented in the ongoing dispute.
They argue that the presidential communication, referenced as PO/17, contains information that contradicts aspects of Rukikaire’s position in the longstanding Incafex dispute.
The siblings allege that the letter has subsequently been used by Alwyn and Rukikaire to justify interventions by security agencies against their mother and their father’s business associates.
The controversy has therefore extended beyond the family succession dispute into a broader corporate confrontation involving competing shareholder claims and government intervention.

Nine bank accounts frozen
Perhaps the most damaging development highlighted in the November 6 statement is the alleged freezing of nine bank accounts belonging to five companies in which Garuga held substantial interests.
The siblings claim that on May 13, 2026, Detective Assistant Inspector of Police Charles Mugerwa, attached to the State House Anti-Corruption Unit, used his position to secure orders that resulted in the closure of the accounts.
According to their account, the orders were obtained during an ex-parte hearing before the Buganda Road Magistrates Court at City Hall.
They allege that the court orders cited a non-existent Bankers Books Act and Sections 8, 9 and 31 of the Computer Misuse Act as the legal basis for the account closures.
The siblings question the circumstances under which the orders were obtained, particularly because the affected companies were allegedly not represented during the proceedings.
They further raise questions about the subsequent legal representation of the police officer.
When the companies sought legal redress to have the accounts reopened, the siblings claim that Mugerwa’s defence was filed by Alwyn and his lawyers rather than the State Attorney.
They say the nine accounts remain closed, leaving the affected businesses struggling to meet their financial obligations.
According to the statement, the companies have accumulated commercial bank loan arrears, unpaid salaries, office rent arrears, outstanding supplier payments, National Social Security Fund obligations and Uganda Revenue Authority tax arrears.
The siblings argue that the restrictions have effectively paralysed businesses that previously operated under their father’s leadership.
They accuse Alwyn and Rukikaire of using the State House Anti-Corruption Unit and the police Land Protection Unit to pursue a campaign that has criminalised otherwise civil disputes.
They also claim that multiple complaints have been lodged against them, resulting in police summons against their mother and other family members, as well as criminal charges against some of their father’s business associates.
These allegations raise questions about the boundaries between legitimate investigations into suspected wrongdoing and the use of state institutions in private commercial disputes.
However, the allegations contained in the family statement have not, by themselves, established misconduct by the named officers or the illegality of the court orders.

Lyantonde farm raid adds another dimension
The family confrontation has also taken a potentially dangerous turn, with reports of armed security personnel being deployed at properties linked to the late businessman.
Last week, a reported incident at a farm in Lyantonde District brought the dispute into sharper focus after approximately 15-armed men allegedly raided the property, brutalised its occupant and destroyed property.
The farm is reportedly among the properties that the late Garuga had sold while he was still alive.
The new owner maintains that the transaction was completed before Garuga’s death and that the property should not be treated as part of the deceased businessman’s estate.
However, individuals reportedly claiming to act on behalf of the estate have sought to assert control over the property.
The reported raid has raised questions about the authority under which the armed men were deployed and whether the operation was backed by a valid court order.
A report published on November 15 by Western Pearl Reports described an incident involving businessman Emmanuel Mugisha Masesane and armed private guards at Ranch No. 15 in Kyemamba village, Lyantonde District.
The report alleged that the businessman was attacked and detained by guards reportedly deployed in connection with the dispute.
It also cited correspondence from a private security company seeking police clearance for the deployment of armed guards and an earlier police authorisation permitting the hiring of private security personnel in the interest of preserving the late Garuga’s estate.
The report raises an important distinction: permission to deploy private security personnel to protect property does not, in itself, determine ownership of disputed land or authorise the eviction, assault or detention of its lawful occupants.
The precise circumstances of the reported confrontation, the legal status of the land and whether the operation was supported by a specific court order require clarification from the relevant authorities.
For the three siblings, however, the incident reinforces their argument that the estate dispute is increasingly being pursued through intimidation rather than the ordinary legal processes.

The earlier public spat between mother and son
The latest statement follows an increasingly bitter public exchange between Peace and Alwyn that became particularly visible during the first memorial service for Garuga in August 2026.
Speaking at All Saints Cathedral in Kampala on August 8, 2026, Peace publicly rejected allegations her son had reportedly made against her and their family’s longtime business associates.
She accused Alwyn of making false and damaging allegations immediately after his father’s death, arguing that he had failed to allow the family sufficient time to mourn before embarking on a public campaign against her.
Peace also revisited the history of disagreements between Alwyn and his father, claiming that the two had been estranged following earlier legal disputes.
She accused her son of teaming up with Rukikaire to pursue numerous court cases involving companies in which Garuga held interests.
The widow also defended the family’s longtime business associate, Canon Agaba Maguru, whose involvement in the companies has featured prominently in the disputes.
Alwyn, on the other hand, has questioned decisions made concerning his father’s businesses and property and raised allegations about the circumstances surrounding Garuga’s final medical treatment.
He has reportedly accused his mother and other individuals of frustrating efforts to secure specialised medical treatment for his father abroad.
Peace rejected the accusations, maintaining that the family had made decisions in the circumstances available to them.
The accusations surrounding Garuga’s final illness and medical care remain contested and should not be treated as established facts.
The August memorial service effectively transformed what had initially been a family succession disagreement into a public confrontation, with both sides using media platforms and legal proceedings to defend their respective positions.
Koome Island land transaction adds to the tensions
Another major flashpoint is the disputed sale of land on Koome Island, which is the subject of Civil Suit No. 343 of 2025 before the High Court in Mukono.
Alwyn has challenged the transaction involving businessman Mani Stephen, Erunger Property Limited and the Commissioner for Land Registration.
However, the three siblings insist that their late father sold the land in 2024 while he was in good health and of sound mind.
They further maintain that the purchase money was paid directly into Garuga’s personal account and that the transaction was properly registered, with the necessary taxes paid.
They accuse Alwyn of pursuing legal action despite what they describe as documentary evidence confirming that their father personally authorised the transaction.
The disagreement illustrates the wider problem facing the administration of Garuga’s estate: determining which properties belonged to him personally, which were held through companies and which transactions were completed before his death.
These distinctions are critical because the personal estate of a deceased individual is legally different from the assets of companies in which that individual held shares.
Consequently, disagreements over company ownership cannot automatically be resolved through the succession process without considering the separate legal status of the companies.

A family feud with wider business implications
The latest statement by Rowena, Johnnie and Phillip is significant because it demonstrates that Alwyn’s position within the family is contested by three of his four siblings.
Their decision to publicly stand behind their mother also undermines any suggestion that the succession dispute represents a united family position.
But beyond the personal disagreements, the dispute threatens businesses, employees, creditors, suppliers and individuals who conducted transactions with Garuga during his lifetime.
The reported freezing of company accounts, competing claims over land and deployment of armed personnel risk turning a succession dispute into a much wider commercial and security crisis.
The High Court’s decision to appoint the Administrator General as temporary administrator was intended to prevent precisely the kind of disruption that can arise when beneficiaries cannot agree on the management of an estate.
The latest accusations therefore place renewed attention on the need for a transparent determination of the estate’s assets, liabilities, shareholding structures and outstanding legal claims.
They also raise questions about the role of the police and other state agencies in disputes involving privately owned companies and contested properties.
For now, the three siblings insist that their mother should be entrusted with the administration of their late father’s estate, while Alwyn continues to challenge her position through legal proceedings.
What began as a disagreement over who should inherit and administer a wealthy businessman’s estate has evolved into a complicated battle involving family relationships, corporate control, presidential correspondence, police interventions and contested land transactions.
With the Administrator General temporarily in charge and several disputes still before different legal and administrative institutions, the final battle for Garuga’s business empire is far from over.
Author Profile

- Mr. Stephen Kasozi Muwambi is a seasoned crime investigative writer, majoring in judicial-based stories. His two decades’ experience as a senior investigative journalist has made him one of the best to reckon on in Uganda. He can also be reached via [email protected]
Latest entries
FeaturedNovember 16, 2026URA’S PLOT TO TAX WHATSAPP CALLS EXPOSED! URA Commissioner General John Musinguzi Warns That Cheaper Internet-Based Calls Are Eroding Taxes Collected From Conventional Voice Services, With Rising Data Revenue Failing To Close The Gap
FeaturedNovember 16, 2026INSIDE THE KING OYO FOUNDATION: Four Months After The Death Of The 34-Year-Old Tooro Monarch, His Family Has Launched A Foundation To Preserve His Memory Through Education, Youth Empowerment, Tourism, Conservation And Agriculture
FeaturedNovember 16, 2026GARUGA ESTATE WAR: THREE CHILDREN DRAW BATTLE LINES AGAINST ALWYN: Rowena, Johnnie and Phillip Musinguzi Rally Behind Their Widowed Mother Peace, Accusing Their Elder Brother Of Frustrating Her Bid To Administer Their Late Father’s Multimillion-Shilling Estate
FeaturedNovember 14, 2026WHY EGESA WAS SNATCHED FROM RADIO ONE: Political Analyst Ronald Leonard Egesa Was Reportedly Bundled Into An Unmarked Van Shortly After An Akaboozi FM Talk Show, Prompting The Uganda Law Society To Condemn The Incident As An Abduction And Demand His Immediate Release
























